1982

5 years later, Paula and Phoebe are both 18 years old. While at an arts show located in Pittsburg, Caroline shows up and shows him pictures of Phoebe. He briefly speaks to an art critic and Caroline leaves. David visits his parents abandoned house where he finds a pregnant 16 year old girl named Rosemary. He reveals his secret to Rosemary and he asks her to come and live with him. Shocked by David’s behavior, David and Norah believe that Rosemary and David have sexual relations. After spending time with Rosemary, Paul learns the truth, but remains upset with his father. Paul steals his neighbors car and gets arrested and his parents come to get him. Paul is accepted at Julliard.